Woman meditating in yoga position on the top of mountains

Divine Rights and Human Rights

The eminent political theorist Harvey Mansfield once wrote that the “religious question” is the crucial one for the modern age, because it concerns the ultimate repository of authority and control. Is it human or is it divine? “All pre-modern regimes,” said Mansfield, “are more or less based on divine right, on appeal to a principle that…

A State Bankruptcy Policy and the Constitution: Michael McConnell Responds

I am grateful to Jonathan Rodden, Jason Sorens, and Steve Slivinski for their thoughtful responses to my essay, entitled Extending Bankruptcy…

The Welfare State’s War of All Against All

I prefer to call the "welfare state" the transfer state, because that characterization leaves open the question of whether a…

From the Blog

Mike Rappaport
University of San Diego School of Law

Baude on Tillman on the Constitution’s Provisions Regarding Officers

One of Justice Scalia's primary influences on constitutional law and theory has been the growth…

Toobin on Justice Thomas’ Alleged Arrogance

While I was on vacation, Jeffrey Toobin published a hit piece on Clarence Thomas in…

Reflections on China

I recently visited China for the first time.  Here are some of my impressions. My main…

John O. McGinnis
Northwestern University School of Law

The Welfare State’s War of All Against All

I prefer to call the "welfare state" the transfer state, because that characterization leaves open…

May’s Ministry Is Another Sign of Trouble for Liberty

Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher together moved the world decisively back toward classical liberal principles…

Regulators, Hands Off the Autopilot!

Tesla provides an autopilot that allows its cars to drive themselves in certain circumstances. Recently,…

Michael S. Greve
George Mason University Law School

Hang in There, RBG: The Country Needs You

Like Mike Rappaport and much of the broader world, I’ve been baffled by Justice Ruth…

The Migrating Power of the Purse

Chris DeMuth, an occasional contributor to this site, and yours truly have penned an exploratory…

This Realm, This England

I sure hope the Brits vote “Leave” on June 23. That would be the first…

Liberty Law Forum

Illinois State Legislature

Extending Bankruptcy Law to States: Is It Constitutional?

Puerto Rico cannot pay its debts. A significant number of states—with Illinois leading the way—teeter on the brink of fiscal disaster. Expenditures exceed revenues; debt service is a rising percentage of budgets; pension liabilities are woefully underfunded; credit ratings plummet; time is running out. If these states were private corporations, and even if they were cities,…

Read More

Responses

Sovereignty and Orderly Defaults

In his illuminating and timely Liberty Forum essay on the constitutional impediments to a state-level bankruptcy procedure, Michael McConnell emphasizes the importance of the sovereignty of the states in the framework of American federalism. Unlike Detroit and San Bernardino, and perhaps unlike Puerto Rico, the states are considered fully sovereign with respect to taxation, expenditures,…

Read More

State Bankruptcy and the Federal Order

While a federal bankruptcy law for states might be a desirable policy, its constitutionality is doubtful. Now, I am not a constitutional lawyer and cannot speak to the details of United States case law, but I do study fiscal federalism in comparative context: its conditions, operations, and consequences. Accordingly, I will analyze how a federal…

Read More

In What Circumstances Would the Threat of State Bankruptcy Be Credible?

Michael McConnell’s Liberty Forum essay does an excellent job of outlining the legal case that enabling states to declare bankruptcy is not necessarily inconsistent with constitutional principles or with existing case law. From the perspective of a public choice economist, however, there is another salient issue. What those who study the outcomes of institutional arrangements and…

Read More

A State Bankruptcy Policy and the Constitution: Michael McConnell Responds

I am grateful to Jonathan Rodden, Jason Sorens, and Steve Slivinski for their thoughtful responses to my essay, entitled Extending Bankruptcy Law to States: Is It Constitutional? I am particularly grateful because they addressed the many public policy issues about state bankruptcy, which I did not. I confined my essay to the legal/constitutional questions. But the…

Read More