• About
  • Contact
  • Staff

Law & Liberty

A Project of Liberty Fund

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Liberty Law Forum
  • Podcasts
  • Book Reviews

January 7, 2014|Economic growth, Entrepreneur, GDP

The Mismeasure of the Economy

by John O. McGinnis|2 Comments

Economic growth and inequality are among the political matters most discussed these days. It is often thought that economy is more stagnant compared to the  buoyant days of the middle of the last century and economic inequality much more pronounced. Politicians offer new government programs as remedies for these perceived reversals.

My skepticism about such claims has a common core. The government has difficulty measuring economic growth and inequality, particularly in an age of accelerating technology. A centralized decision maker cannot create a set of rules to pin down an ever changing and dynamic economy.

Famously, socialist governments in the last century wrongly thought they could calculate the appropriate prices for goods. Today calculation problems also beset government  measurement of growth and inequality. In this post and in the next, I will take up economic growth. I will then discuss economic inequality.

Measuring the real rate economic growth requires the government to calculate the rate of inflation. That determination in turn requires the government to calculate the change in the price of a basket of goods that people buy. But the goods in the basket are changing as well. Unless the basket reflects the added value of innovations, inflation will be systematically overstated and growth systematically understated.

In a static world where goods did change much, correcting for innovation may not have been difficult. But we live an age of technological acceleration. Computer chips double in power every two years. The result of such exponential growth  is a rapid introduction of new products, like tablets and smart phones. Moreover, computation transforms  ever more products. Cars, for instance, now add new computerized features every year, from automatic parallel parking to adaptive cruise control. Cars are becoming computers on wheels and in the next decade will be autonomous.

How can government decision makers accurately compare the value of such devices to those they replace, particularly when they are so innovative that they have no close substitutes in the previous era? While the comparisons may be relatively successful year to year, even small mistakes repeated over time can seriously distort long-term measurements.

Let me close with two concrete examples that suggest the degree to which computational technology is making us better off—one small and one large. In 1973 my father gave me an HP-35 calculator costing 400 dollars (2000 in today’s dollars). I can download an essentially equivalent calculator for nothing. (For those less interested in mathematics, substitute access to free and ubiquitous music of your choice).

For me and for many other Americans the internet may be the most transformative good of all. Americans spend about thirteen weeks online. The internet permits us to work and play connected to others as never before. When I was young, I would have dismissed the idea of the internet as something akin to magic.  Magic is hard to measure.

In the next post, I will argue that government calculated growth rates do not capture the improvements in health care and respond to a few potential objections.

John O. McGinnis

John O. McGinnis is the George C. Dix Professor in Constitutional Law at Northwestern University. His book Accelerating Democracy was published by Princeton University Press in 2012. McGinnis is also the coauthor with Mike Rappaport of Originalism and the Good Constitution published by Harvard University Press in 2013 . He is a graduate of Harvard College, Balliol College, Oxford, and Harvard Law School. He has published in leading law reviews, including the Harvard, Chicago, and Stanford Law Reviews and the Yale Law Journal, and in journals of opinion, including National Affairs and National Review.

About the Author

McGinnis and Rappaport at the Volokh Conspiracy
The War on Poverty Turns 50

Recent Popular Posts

  • Popular
  • Today Week Month All
  • Immigration Cases Make Strange Bedfellows. But Is It a Long-Term Relationship? April 26, 2018
  • Making Our Universities a Source of Universal Knowledge April 26, 2018
  • Kubrick’s Odyssey at 50 April 26, 2018
  • The Successes and Failure of John Quincy Adams September 18, 2014
  • Moneyball Illustrates Efficient Markets, Not Behavioral Economics April 26, 2018
Ajax spinner

Related Posts

Related

Comments

  1. JD says

    January 8, 2014 at 11:13 am

    There are some hedonic price adjustments made to CPI, although, it probably isn’t as robust as it needs to be. http://www.bls.gov/cpi/cpihqaitem.htm

    Reply
  2. R Richard Schweitzer says

    January 8, 2014 at 12:02 pm

    In your next posts will you also take up variations in motivations and the effects of political determinations on those motivations?

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Book Reviews

The Ford Restoration

by Kirk Emmert

Occupying the White House in unfavorable circumstances can make a President fall back on his best friend: the U.S. Constitution.

Read More

John C. Calhoun, Madisonian Manqué

by Thomas W. Merrill

His institutional innovations were geared toward preserving slavery.

Read More

Podcasts

The Solid Ground of Mere Civility: A Conversation with Teresa Bejan

A discussion with Teresa M. Bejan

Teresa Bejan discusses with us how early modern debates over religious toleration are an example of how we can disagree well.

Read More

Leading a Worthy Life in a Scattered Time: A Conversation with Leon Kass

A discussion with Leon Kass

Leon Kass discusses Leading a Worthy Life.

Read More

Eric Voegelin Studies: A Conversation with Charles Embry

A discussion with Charles Embry

What did “Don’t immanentize the eschaton!” really mean? An intro podcast on the formidable mind of Eric Voegelin.

Read More

Republican Virtue, Interrupted: A Conversation with Frank Buckley

A discussion with F.H. Buckley

The real conflict in our politics centers on reforming massive levels of public corruption.

Read More

Recent Posts

  • Kubrick’s Odyssey at 50

    The movie that inserted existentialism into our understanding of science fiction on screen.
    by Titus Techera

  • Immigration Cases Make Strange Bedfellows. But Is It a Long-Term Relationship?

    Dimaya v. Sessions is a milestone simply because the Court struck down a provision of immigration law, but it has wider implications.
    by Michael Kagan

  • Making Our Universities a Source of Universal Knowledge

    The distance between the humanities and sciences has grown wider since C.P. Snow discussed it six decades ago in "The Two Cultures." We need both.
    by John O. McGinnis

  • Moneyball Illustrates Efficient Markets, Not Behavioral Economics

    Many have the story of Moneyball wrong: it's not a story of systematic error but one of eliminating systematic error in a market.
    by James R. Rogers

  • Academic Freedom Won’t Survive Carnival Act Universities

    Public institutions of supposedly liberal learning, which are increasingly alienating mainstream Americans, have no entitlement to public support.
    by Greg Weiner

Blogroll

  • Acton PowerBlog
  • Cafe Hayek
  • Cato@Liberty
  • Claremont
  • Congress Shall Make No Law
  • EconLog
  • Fed Soc Blog
  • First Things
  • Hoover
  • ISI First Principles Journal
  • Legal Theory Blog
  • Marginal Revolution
  • Pacific Legal Liberty Blog
  • Point of Law
  • Power Line
  • Professor Bainbridge
  • Ricochet
  • Right Reason
  • Spengler
  • The American
  • The Beacon Blog
  • The Foundry
  • The Originalism Blog
  • The Public Discourse
  • University Bookman
  • Via Meadia
  • Volokh

Archives

  • All Posts & Publications
  • Book Reviews
  • Liberty Forum
  • Liberty Law Blog
  • Liberty Law Talk

About

Law and Liberty’s focus is on the content, status, and development of law in the context of republican and limited government and the ways that liberty and law and law and liberty mutually reinforce the other. This site brings together serious debate, commentary, essays, book reviews, interviews, and educational material in a commitment to the first principles of law in a free society. Law and Liberty considers a range of foundational and contemporary legal issues, legal philosophy, and pedagogy.

  • Home
  • About
  • Staff
  • Contact
  • Archive

Apple App Store
Google Play Store

© 2018 Liberty Fund, Inc.

Subscribe
Get Law and Liberty's latest content delivered to you daily
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
No thanks